How nearly four decades of clinical collaboration have shaped my understanding of hypnosis, autonomic regulation and the treatment of complex patients.

Introduction

Clinical hypnosis is often misunderstood. For many people, the word immediately conjures up images of stage hypnotists, swinging watches and individuals apparently surrendering control of their minds.

The reality of clinical hypnotherapy is very different.

For almost 40 years, I have had the privilege of working closely with my friend and colleague, Dr Brian Roet, an Australian doctor who originally trained in general practice and anaesthesia before developing his career in clinical hypnotherapy and psychotherapy.

Brian was also part of The Health Equation clinical team for approximately ten years.

Over the decades, we have shared hundreds of patients, held countless clinical discussions and lectured together. These experiences have profoundly influenced my understanding of the relationship between the brain, the autonomic nervous system and physical health.

I have consequently been a longstanding advocate of clinical hypnotherapy, particularly when appropriately integrated into the management of patients with complex or persistent symptoms.

A recent Medscape article exploring the applications of clinical hypnosis beyond pain relief prompted me to reflect on why this approach deserves a much more prominent place in modern clinical thinking.

Gerry at The Health Equation – Spotify Podcast

In this episode, Gerry explores the science and clinical applications of hypnosis, drawing on almost four decades of collaboration with Dr Brian Roet, a medical doctor, clinical hypnotherapist and psychotherapist.

We discuss how hypnosis may influence pain, anxiety, sleep and physiological responses, and why its potential relationship with autonomic regulation is particularly relevant to patients with complex symptoms.

We also explore the importance of distinguishing genuine physical pathology from the regulatory processes that can amplify or perpetuate symptoms.

Please follow this show on Spotify. It really helps!

Gerry Gajadharsingh writes:

Nearly 40 years of learning from a colleague

When I first met Brian Roet almost four decades ago, I was still relatively early in my osteopathic career.

Brian had already followed an interesting professional journey, having trained as a GP and anaesthetist in Australia before moving into clinical hypnotherapy and psychotherapy.

What particularly interested me was his ability to approach patients from both a conventional medical perspective and an understanding of the psychological and neurological processes influencing their symptoms.

Over the years, our clinical discussions have frequently centred on patients whose presentations did not fit neatly into conventional diagnostic categories.

These were not necessarily patients without identifiable pathology. Often, they had several overlapping problems, with symptoms that seemed disproportionate to individual structural or biochemical findings.

Brian and I would frequently approach the same patient from different but complementary perspectives.

My work focused on the interaction between musculoskeletal function, breathing, physiological regulation and other biological systems. His work explored how attention, perception, emotional responses and learned patterns might influence the patient’s experience.

The benefit was not that one approach was inherently superior to the other.

It was that we were asking different questions about the same patient.

That experience helped reinforce a principle that has become central to my clinical reasoning: understanding a diagnosis is not necessarily the same as understanding the individual patient.

What exactly is clinical hypnosis?

Clinical hypnosis involves directing attention towards a particular experience, often using verbal guidance, imagery and therapeutic suggestion.

Contrary to popular belief, patients do not become unconscious or surrender control to the practitioner.

Instead, hypnosis typically involves focused attention, reduced awareness of competing stimuli and an increased capacity to respond to appropriate suggestions.

These suggestions may be directed towards reducing pain, changing an uncomfortable sensation, improving relaxation or developing a greater sense of control over symptoms.

The mechanisms are not fully understood, but research suggests that hypnosis can influence neural networks involved in attention, perception and the interpretation of sensory information.

This is particularly interesting because it demonstrates that conscious experience is not simply a passive reflection of what is happening in the tissues.

Pain is more than a signal from damaged tissue

One of the most important lessons from decades of clinical practice is that pain cannot always be explained by the severity of tissue damage.

Two patients may have remarkably similar MRI findings yet experience completely different levels of pain and disability.

One may continue exercising, working and sleeping normally. The other may experience persistent pain, disturbed sleep, muscle guarding and increasing anxiety about movement.

This does not mean that the second patient’s symptoms are imaginary.

Pain is a genuine biological experience, involving sensory information, inflammation, previous experiences, attention, expectation, emotional context and the state of the nervous system.

In persistent pain, neural pathways may become increasingly sensitive, amplifying symptoms even when the original tissue injury has healed or is no longer the principal driver.

Clinical hypnosis may help some patients modify the way these signals are processed and experienced.

Research supports modest benefits for certain pain conditions, although hypnosis has not consistently demonstrated superiority over other established interventions such as relaxation, pain education or cognitive behavioural therapy.

It is therefore best understood as a potentially useful component of an individualised treatment programme rather than a universal solution.

Clinical hypnosis and the autonomic nervous system

This is the area that particularly interests me.

For nearly two decades, I have incorporated capnometry and heart rate variability measurements into my assessment of selected patients, exploring the relationships between breathing, carbon dioxide regulation, autonomic function and clinical symptoms.

The autonomic nervous system continuously adjusts physiological activity in response to internal and external demands.

Heart rate, vascular tone, respiratory behaviour, gastrointestinal function and many other processes are influenced by this complex regulatory network.

In patients experiencing persistent pain, anxiety or other complex symptoms, physiological responses may become less flexible or poorly matched to the demands of the situation.

Some patients demonstrate altered breathing patterns, excessive respiratory effort or difficulty returning to a comfortable resting state.

Clinical hypnotherapy interests me because it offers a different potential route into some of these regulatory processes.

Rather than beginning with manual treatment, breathing retraining or physical rehabilitation, hypnosis works primarily through focused attention, imagery, suggestion and changes in the interpretation of bodily experience.

These processes may influence perceived threat, emotional arousal and certain physiological responses.

However, it is important to distinguish plausible mechanisms from established clinical outcomes.

We cannot assume that hypnosis directly normalises end-tidal carbon dioxide, improves heart rate variability or corrects autonomic dysfunction.

Nevertheless, the interaction between attention, expectation, breathing behaviour and autonomic responses provides a compelling area for further investigation.

Different approaches, shared clinical reasoning

One of the great advantages of working alongside Brian was recognising that patients often benefit when clinicians approach their problems from different directions.

A patient presenting with chronic neck or back pain, for example, may have a genuine musculoskeletal problem requiring physical treatment.

However, they may also have developed persistent protective muscle guarding, altered breathing behaviour, disturbed sleep and increased vigilance towards bodily sensations.

Manual treatment may improve local movement and reduce nociceptive input.

Breathing retraining may help address dysfunctional respiratory patterns.

Clinical hypnotherapy may assist the patient in modifying their relationship with pain, reducing perceived threat or developing greater confidence in their ability to manage symptoms.

These approaches are not mutually exclusive.

Nor does every patient require all of them.

The clinical challenge is to identify which mechanisms are contributing most significantly to the individual patient’s presentation.

Having shared hundreds of patients with Brian over the years, I have become increasingly convinced of the value of this collaborative approach.

Importantly, that conviction arises from clinical experience. It should not be confused with proof that combining these interventions produces superior outcomes for every patient.

Beyond pain: anxiety and physiological stress

Clinical hypnosis has also been investigated in patients undergoing medical procedures.

A 2025 systematic review and meta-analysis involving 20 randomised controlled trials and 1,250 patients reported reductions in procedural anxiety and pain, together with improvements in certain physiological stress measures, including heart rate and blood pressure.

These findings are particularly relevant because they suggest that hypnosis may influence both the subjective experience of a stressful event and aspects of the accompanying physiological response.

For clinicians interested in autonomic regulation, this is an important observation.

However, changes in heart rate or blood pressure do not, by themselves, establish a specific autonomic mechanism.

They provide evidence of physiological effects that require careful interpretation.

Sleep, menopause and other applications

Clinical hypnosis has also been investigated for sleep disturbance, menopausal vasomotor symptoms and certain functional conditions.

Studies involving menopausal women have reported reductions in hot flush frequency following structured hypnosis interventions.

This is potentially valuable for women who cannot or prefer not to use hormonal treatments.

Similarly, hypnosis may help selected patients whose sleep disturbance is associated with anxiety, cognitive arousal or difficulty disengaging from intrusive thoughts.

However, the evidence varies between conditions, and established treatments should not be displaced without appropriate clinical justification.

For chronic insomnia, cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia remains an established first-line intervention.

The important point is that hypnosis may have applications beyond pain, but each proposed application needs to be evaluated on its own evidence.

The Integrated Regulatory Systems Framework

My Integrated Regulatory Systems Framework (IRSF™) considers health through the interaction of seven physiological systems:

  • Respiratory
  • Neural
  • Circulatory
  • Endocrine
  • Immune & Inflammatory
  • Metabolic
  • Musculoskeletal

Clinical hypnosis is primarily a neural and behavioural intervention, but its potential effects may extend into other systems through changes in perception, behaviour and physiological responses.

For example, reducing anxiety may improve sleep, which can subsequently influence pain tolerance, fatigue and aspects of metabolic regulation.

Changes in perceived threat may also influence muscle guarding, breathing behaviour and the experience of bodily discomfort.

These interactions are biologically plausible, although not every proposed downstream effect has been demonstrated specifically for hypnosis.

This is precisely why I believe integrated clinical reasoning is so important.

We should not assume that one intervention regulates every physiological system. Equally, we should not overlook the potential for interventions directed towards one system to influence others.

Why I remain an advocate of clinical hypnotherapy

My enthusiasm for clinical hypnotherapy is not based on the belief that it can cure every condition.

It comes from almost four decades of observing, discussing and learning from a colleague whose clinical perspective has complemented my own.

Brian and I have approached many difficult patients together, often exploring different dimensions of the same clinical problem.

Our collaboration has reinforced my belief that effective healthcare requires more than identifying structural abnormalities, prescribing medication or attaching diagnostic labels.

It requires an understanding of how the individual patient is functioning, adapting and responding to their circumstances.

Clinical hypnotherapy can provide another useful therapeutic option within that broader approach.

Of course, it must be practised responsibly, by appropriately trained professionals, and should never be used to dismiss genuine pathology or delay necessary investigation.

But equally, it would be a mistake to disregard a potentially valuable intervention simply because its mechanisms involve attention, perception and psychological processes.

These are not separate from biology.

They are part of it.

Conclusion: The importance of understanding the whole patient

Clinical hypnosis illustrates something that I have increasingly come to appreciate throughout my professional career.

The brain is not simply a passive observer of what happens in the body. It actively participates in the interpretation and regulation of physiological experience.

Pain, anxiety, sleep disturbance and many other symptoms emerge from interactions between tissue pathology, sensory processing, previous experience and physiological regulation.

The evidence supporting clinical hypnosis is encouraging in selected settings, particularly pain and procedural anxiety, although the magnitude and consistency of benefits vary.

For me, the wider lesson is also a personal one.

Working with Brian Roet for almost 40 years has reinforced the importance of professional curiosity, interdisciplinary collaboration and recognising that no single clinical discipline has all the answers.

We should neither reduce every symptom to structural disease nor assume that symptoms without obvious structural explanations are purely psychological.

The challenge is to understand the whole patient, identify the relevant physiological and behavioural mechanisms, and select the most appropriate combination of interventions.

That is the foundation of good clinical reasoning.

Clinical Disclaimer

This article is intended for general education and discussion of medical research. It does not constitute individual medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Clinical hypnosis should be considered only following appropriate assessment and, where indicated, under the supervision of a suitably qualified healthcare professional. Patients should not discontinue prescribed treatments or delay medical investigation on the basis of this information.

References and Further Reading

  1. Hypnosis in Clinical Practice: Beyond Pain Relief. 2026. Original article.
  2. A Systematic Review of Hypnosis for Clinical Pain Relief.European Journal of Pain. 2026. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejp.70369
  3. The Use of Medical Hypnosis to Prevent and Treat Acute and Chronic Pain: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.Journal of Clinical Medicine. 2025;14(13):4661. https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm14134661
  4. Hypnosis as a Non-Pharmacological Intervention for Invasive Medical Procedures: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analytic Update.Journal of Psychosomatic Research. 2025;192:112117. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpsychores.2025.112117
  5. Weir K.Uncovering the New Science of Clinical Hypnosis. American Psychological Association. 2024. https://www.apa.org/monitor/2024/04/science-of-hypnosis

Main Article

Hypnosis in Clinical Practice: Beyond Pain Relief. Medscape, 2026.

Read the original Medscape article

This commentary is independently written for The Health Equation and does not reproduce the original publication.